Wednesday, September 10, 2014

My Husband's Shirt: Collar and Collar Stand

During the Fall of 2012, I took a Men's Shirtmaking class at the Fashion Institute of Technology in New York City.  I loved this course.  I took it because I noticed that men's shirts are better made and more durable than women's blouses.  I think many women's ready-to-wear blouses are flimsy.  You have more control over the quality of a woman's blouse when you make it yourself, of course, but I wanted to learn... what was it about a man's shirt that made it look so crisp and polished?




In this post, I will share the most novel information (at least to me) I learned in class.  They are techniques I do not see described in pattern instructions.  My professor told us they are the techniques used in the factories overseas (for the most part - they use a lot less pins and they have specialized equipment to make the super pointy collar and precise sleeve plackets).  I found that I have been able to create some high quality professional-looking shirts using the techniques learned in class.  Some of them may surprise you!

In sewing, there is always more than one way to do something so what I was taught is not the only way and may or may not work for you.

Besides using good quality 100% cotton shirting for the shirt featured here, I found that using good quality interfacing is also key to a professional result.   I found a medium weight non-woven interfacing designed specifically for collars and cuffs at SIL on 38th Street between 7th and 8th Avenues.  It came prepackaged in a ziploc type of bag.  You can also find good quality interfacing at Steinlauf and Stoller in New York City.  I always test different types of interfacing on scraps of fabric to make sure I like the resulting hand and feel.

The interfaced side of the collar and cuffs are the "public" side.  In class, I was amazed to learn that you do not use steam when applying fusible interfacing.  The professor was emphatic about this and other professors teaching other courses at FIT have said the same thing.  The steam creates a water vapor that acts like a barrier to having the glue adhere 100%.

So here goes!

1.  All seam allowances are 1/2 inch, except for the neckline, collar and collar stand which are 1/4 inch.  In the photo below, the collar has been inserted into the collar stand. The interfaced collar and interfaced side of the collar stand are facing up.  The collar stand has been folded up by 1/4 inch and topstitched exposing the 1/4 seam allowance of the uninterfaced collar stand.  It is wavy at the bottom (as it should be) because it is a round shape that I have placed onto a flat surface:


2.  Mark the uninterfaced bottom side of the collar stand using the folded interfaced edge as a guide.  Angle your marking tool toward the folded edge as you mark:



3.  What follows is a little bit of MAGIC!  It is commonplace to find when you attach the collar stand to the main garment that there is a "jog" or "bump" at the edge where the collar stand meets the front opening of the garment.  You can avoid this with a pin!

When you pin the collar stand to the garment, extend the garment edge by 1/16 inch beyond the collar stand and place a pin close to the edge to hold this "mismatch" in place:


Pin more of the collar stand to the garment neckline edge for a couple of inches, matching the raw edges.  Then sew for one inch.  Do the same on the other end.  Why only one inch?  Because you will be tucking in the seam allowance into the collar stand to see how you like the edge.  If you don't like it, you have only one inch of stitching to undo and re-do.

IMPORTANT:  When you sew the one inch, you MUST NOT REMOVE THE PIN.  If you do, you will lose the 1/16 inch "mismatch."  Do not use the foot pedal when sewing over the pin or you risk damaging the machine or breaking your needle.  Hand crank the machine slowly and carefully.  I placed a swatch of folded interfaced fabric behind the presser foot as I started to make the foot level with the amount of fabric at the start of the collar stand.


The "mismatch" will produce the following clean edge.  See how there is no jog or bump! MAGIC.  Do the same on the other end.


It takes some degree of finesse but I find it is worth it in the end.  The first time I did it, I mangled the collar stand so much that the fabric shredded and I had to cut and sew another collar stand and repair the garment neckline edge with a bit of interfacing.  I mangled it because I did not make the foot level with the amount of fabric at the end so the feed dogs ate the fabric at the bottom and the needle just pierced the fabric on top in the same place over and over.  And then of course I didn't get those nice clean edges so I stitched and unstitched and stitched and unstitched and….

Anyway, I got the above clean edge on this shirt on my 2nd try.

4.  Once you are satisfied with the ends, continue pinning the rest of the collar stand to the neckline edge matching the raw edges.  Sew along the chalk marking you did previously from Step 2.

5.  Once you have completely sewn the collar stand to the garment neckline edge, tuck the seam allowance upward inside the collar stand.  Pin along the fold making sure to cover the stitching you just did in step 4 ever so slightly.  The folded edge should just meet the stitch line ever so slightly.


6.  Then edge stitch along the fold.  If you successfully placed the fold "ever so slightly," when you fold the collar stand back, the previous line of stitching attaching the uninterfaced collar stand to the garment neckline edge will be visible:


And then the front of the collar stand will look like this:


And the back of the collar stand will look like this:

You see how I caught the back and front with the same line of stitching?  That's because I placed the fold "ever so slightly…" over the line of stitching from Steps 3 and 4.  It takes some practice.  Certainly the first time I did this, I did not have this result.

The first photo above is the collar open and here is the collar closed:



Anyway, I am happy with the results.

My next post will address how to sew a flat fell seam inside a sleeve.


15 comments:

  1. I really like this! I have been wanting to make my husband a shirt but haven't found the right pattern.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much! There aren't that many patterns for men out there but keep looking. One day you will find the right one.

      Delete
  2. WOW! what a lot of info in this post!! Someday I will try to make a button down shirt again and when I do, I will come back to these directions!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. p.s. I wonder if you and Peter had the same professor!

      Delete
    2. Thank you Kyle! I am glad you find my post informative. I will have to ask Peter someday whom he took. It's most likely the same professor!

      Delete
  3. Impressive work, Tomara. A few button down shirts are on my list. These tips will come in handy. Thank you for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Cennetta! I am glad you found some useful tips.

      Delete
  4. Love this Tomasita! I felt at home reading your beautiful post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Enrique! I am glad you enjoyed my post.

      Delete
  5. Your shirt posts are going to be my bookmarks for great quality shirts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! I am quite flattered!

      Delete
  6. Just to be clear, do you use heat only to apply fusible interfacing to the collar, collar stand, etc., rather than heat and moisture as steam?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, you are correct. I use dry heat only. No steam. According to what I was taught, the steam creates a water vapor that causes the fusible not to adhere as well as it could. Think of it this way, when you are glueing two objects together (paper or cardboard or you're trying to fix a toy), would you mix a little bit of water in with the glue? You would not. So the same thinking applies with fabric. I was floored when I was taught this because oftentimes, instructions that come with fusible interfacing and many sewing articles tell you to use steam. However, I have applied interfacing without steam and have had good results. I have washed my husband's shirts and the fusible stayed intact.

      Delete
  7. I really have to thank you for this. I have read (literally) everyone's posts, methods, tips, suggestions etc. (If it's been written, I've probably read it)for attaching a collar and collar band to a shirt. Until now, my efforts have only been minimally successful at best. I read this post a few months back and bookmarked it intending to practice it once I had a chance but never got around to it. Then to day, I found myself in the middle of making a shirt and this post once I got to attaching the collar and collar band. Your instructions, and pictures were PERFECT!! iI was already pretty proud of how well I'd constructed the collar and band and this method for attaching this to the shirt was the piece de resistance. It went together perfectly in one try. Thank you!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are quite welcome! I am so happy my post was helpful and that my instructions helped you succeed. You have made my day. And kudos to you for getting it in one try - impressive!

      Delete